I don't identify myself as a witch. Mostly. Sometimes, when joking with friends or family who are "in the know," I do, but generally, I go with "Pagan."
Lately, I've been contemplating the how and why of this, which turns me into a giant nerd AND forces me to contemplate some fairly ugly stereotypes. (Right in the middle of Spring Cleaning. Oof.)
First, the nerdliness. Despite all protestations by witchly folks, it would appear that as early as Old English times (let's say 1066, just for fun) people associated the word "witch" with satanic dealings. The Online Etymological Dictionary throws it back to some IndoEuropean roots that might have been associated with "bending" or "spirit," which is more comfortable for me. However, if you look up the roots of the word, you'll find about 80 bajillion ideas about where the word came from, some clearly biased toward non-demonic roots, some going toward the other end of the spectrum. (Fascinating to nerds like me, frustrating for people like me seeking concrete answers.)
After being fascinated and frustrated, I looked up "Wicca." I expected it to be an ancient word, but found instead its common magical usage to be very modern--dating to 1954 and Gerald Gardner. Huh.
Why all this looking up and frustration? Here's where the stereotyping comes in.
My Soul Sista posted earlier a list of magical questions, designed to make one think about one's practice. I read it with interest, but...many of the questions had nothing to do with me.
I don't have a magical name. I don't have a familiar. I don't think about my practice in terms like that; in fact, trying to decide or be open to my magical name or a familiar or whathaveyou makes me uncomfortable to the point that I squirm.
*Disclaimer here: I'm not trying to offend anybody (most especially my darlin' Boo-ums) when I work my addled brain through this. I want everybody here to be free to be you and me. These are just issues I'm confronting as a fairly new Pagan.*
In my head, whenever somebody identifies herself as a witch, what is immediately conjured up is the image of those folks I knew in high school who wore a lot of purple crushed velvet and dark lipstick. These lovies hung out on the fringes of cafeterias and coffee shops and seemed to take delight in being weird for weird's sake. (I will point out here that they didn't exist in my school. I only saw them out in trips to larger towns and cities.) In college, it was kind of more of the same. Any witches who came out of the broom closet seemed to do so in a swirl of satin and with a few dozen pewter pentagrams hanging from their spiked colors.
Fast forward a few years. I have realized that I've always identified with the concept of a "great Mother"--probably the reason I love the
Clan of the Cave Bear books so much. And Mother Nature. And herbs and folklore and unseen things, etc. I finally become actualized enough to start looking up information about paganism.
And I find--more folks in swirly purple capes. Oh, dear. One of the first books I read was by Raven Silverwolf, and while I appreciated the wit of it, I have to admit that I did (and still do, frankly) consider some of the things she suggested to be totally goofy. As in, "Let's go hang out at the mall and freak out some Christians" goofy. And her name. OOF. It just killed me. I discarded her book, picked up a Scott Cunningham or two (better) and then an Ellen Dugan (aaahhhh, sweet relief...), but I sort of stayed away from anybody with a magical-sounding name. It made me feel twitchy.
Fast forward a year. I meet up with a lady who is graciously helping me try to organize Earth Day in our community. I notice she's wearing a Mother pendant and I flash her my triskele ring. We laugh like goons and give each other big hugs. Yay! And she mentions the local Pagan group she's associated with and I ask, "Are the people there, like, normal? Or are they the moony-hocus-pocusy people?" Because, y'all, I'm an ass. And her face sort of freezes and I realize what an ass I was and then her face goes back to normal and we're fine, but I have totally offended her. I think back to that day now and I just cringe. First, because I missed out on making a friend (or several) right then and there and second, because how awesome am I that I can look down on anybody else and the way they live their life?
I've grown, some, I think, in this regard. A few months ago, I was reading a Pagan blog I occasionally frequent and the writer started talking about people who dress up in cloaks or in leather and lace or whathaveyou to attend festivals or rituals and how cheesy that was and how it shouldn't be allowed and I bristled up into a giant ball of, "How dare a Pagan tell other Pagans how to be?" Then I deflated, because...oh. Right. Ahem. Excuse me while I slink off in embarrassment.
I think my problem with her blog was that the freedom of Paganism from the set rules and rituals of modern Christianity is one of its big draws for me. I find the ability to make up my own rituals, my own set of corresponding beliefs to the knowledge passed down through time to be personally freeing. But, at the end of the day, I'm still more Valerie from
The Princess Bride ("I'm not a witch, I'm your WIFE.") than Sarah from
Hocus Pocus. (Why am I breaking out the movie references now? Couldn't tell you.) I have trouble remembering, much less holding, all of the Sabbats, and as I mentioned on my SS's FB page, some of them leave me cold. (Literally, Imbolc. You were wretchedly cold this year.) I don't have a magical name and will probably never have one, because I don't want to set my magical self aside from my mundane self. I don't have a true altar or a cauldron or any of that stuff. (We've talked about this before.) I don't own a crushed velvet purple cape (although, to be honest, I am kind of in love with the idea of a heathery brown cashmere one. Siiiiigggghhhh.)
At the same time, I feel a connection to the moony-hocusy-pocusy people. We are different. Our souls don't sing the same hymns that our neighbors' do. We honor, in some way, the same sort of entities.
I don't know why this strikes me as so important right now. I suppose that it's nice for me to see a little community forming here and that it's interesting to see so many different sorts of people drawing around a common fire.
Even if we are dressed differently. What do you think?